Murray Light does a good job of spelling out the Democrats' objections to the proposed immigration bill today.
The controversial guest worker program would be capped at 200,000 a
year under the Democratic proposal.
The Bush administration
opposed that cutback from the original plan that would have provided
for 400,000 visas annually, with an option to increase that number to
600,000 if warranted by market conditions. The Democrats said the
temporary work program would create too large a group of second-class
citizens and negatively impact the wages of Americans in some
industries.
[excerpted]
Another ludicrous restriction that makes no good sense at all would
require applicants for permanent residence to return to their home
countries. What purpose that would serve has not been adequately
explained by the framers of the bill. What would this do to those from
distant lands such as China?
Another aspect of the Senate
compromise would set up a point system for future immigration that
places less emphasis on family ties than has existed in the past. This,
too, makes little good sense and is not consistent with American
values. The point system would favor high-skill immigrants, but at the
same time undermines the traditional family basis of our immigration
system.
He ignores Republicans' problems with it, though, and it's those that will kill it. Under the bill, 12 million illegal aliens will be able to apply for legal status and get it within 24 hours. If they don't have a criminal record, they're in -- no fines, no fees and very little hassle. They only pay a fine to apply for citizenship.
If making money, however, is more important than becoming Americans, they simply don't need to bother. This ease of winning legal status would only embolden even more to come here illegally. After giving amnesty to some 3 million illegals in 1986 and doing little since then to stem the entry of even more, this bill only reinforces a precedent -- get into the U.S. -- any way you can. The odds are pretty good we'll let you stay.
While the bill does provide some vague benchmarks to increase border security, many, if not most Republicans simply don't believe they'll be enforced. They're too far in the future and given Congress's seeming willingness to avoid this problem, stand too much chance of being changed before they're even implemented.
The problem of the illegals already here can wait until Washington has shown that the southern border has been shut down to illegal crossings. Then, and only then, we can discuss the niceties of how to go about digesting the 12 million already amongst us without worrying that another wave isn't already rolling in.