Wow! Ross Runfola really hates Thanksgiving.
There is a hypocrisy re-enacting a mythical friendship that resulted in genocide as reprehensible as the Holocaust of World War II. There is general consensus among demographers that between 9 million and 12 million Native Americans were in North America when the Pilgrims came. By the beginning of the 20th century, mass extermination through starvation, forced marches out of their land, intentional exposure to smallpox, military battles, incarceration and attempted enslavement left only approximately 332,400 indigenous people alive
He goes on to label Christopher Columbus a terrorist, does a quick riff on degrading Indian mascots and still finds space to rue the "capital punishment" of 45 million turkeys which we shouldn't be eating anyway because we're not sensible and skinny vegetarians like, um, him.
Now, I don't know about your family but mine spent a truly enjoyable Thanksgiving and didn't even think of Indians for one second let alone re-enact scenes from Plymouth Colony. But I suspect the good Mr. Runfola would consider our lack of concern that day for the plight of America's indigenous peoples as just one more sad symptom of the thoughtless hedonism that has "become part of the American fabric while people in Third World nations like Darfur starve."
Well, we didn't cause the people of Darfur to starve any more than we caused the people of India and China to prosper. In fact, we could send Darfur all 45 million of those murdered turkeys and next year this time its people would still be starving. We needn't feel any more guilty about that than we should over the actions of our ancestors towards the Indians.
Ugly as those actions were by today's standards, they're done with and we had nothing to do with it. And renouncing Thanksgiving won't change a thing -- even symbolically.
So let the five year olds dress up like Pilgrims and Indians and act out the mythical Thanksgiving. There will be plenty of time for them to learn the ugly truth of history when they're older. In the meantime let's think of the day as an allegory for how people should behave towards each other. It's a worthwhile lesson. And, yes, I'm perfectly content that they believe in Santa Claus for a while, too.
And next year, please, consider having a few slices of turkey yourself. It tends to make you sleepy and it sure sounds as if you could use a good, relaxing snooze.